Do your performance appraisals boost productivity?

Citation metadata

Author: James M. Jenks
Date: June 1991
From: Management Review(Vol. 80, Issue 6)
Publisher: American Management Association
Document Type: Article
Length: 1,427 words

Main content

Article Preview :

New managing duties stir up more anxiety between boss and subordinate than scheduled performance appraisals. Yet, Pas are an integral part of the employeeemployer relationship.

So how do you relieve that tension and tap the full benefits of performance appraisal? Training is the best answer. Wen you do them the right way, performance appraisals are key factors in boosting individual productivity and development," says Lester R. Bittel, professor emeritus of management at James Madison University and editor of The Encyclopedia of Management McGraw-Hill).

"Better still," he adds, "managers who are well-trained in conducting appraisals are injecting a dynamic motivating method into their managing styles."

Ifs ironic," Bittel admits. "Most employees really want to know How am I doing? 'but they seldom ask. Many managers would be happy to answer, but they hesitate to take the initiative."

Your first step in training is to make sure that anyone making appraisals understands this rule: Judge the work, not the person. In other words, appraise performance, not personal characteristics. But how do you hammer that rule into your appraisers?

IMPROVING APPRAISERS' SKILLS If your company is like most organizations, it is sure to have on record specific examples of poor appraisals, ones that placed a manager in deep trouble. Combine some of these common appraisal backfires with, for example, the legal fireworks that can flare up. You'll grab your trainees' individual attention with these incidents, and you'll brighten up your training.

Take a case like this: An employee is fired and shortly thereafter claims his career was damaged by the discharge. Dragged into court, the company lays out a personnel record that shows criticism for a bad attitude.

Unfortunately for the company, though, the appraisals report no specific instances of unsatisfactory job performance. There are no comments in the records about failure to meet agreed-upon standards for the job. A litigationminded lawyer easily makes a judge and jury wonder whether the problem was the employee's attitude or the evaluator's. Me result: a big bucks award for the employee; huge legal fees for the company; big headaches for all parties concerned; even personal liability for the individual who did the...

Source Citation

Source Citation Citation temporarily unavailable, try again in a few minutes.   

Gale Document Number: GALE|A10830893