Epidemic: phony medical news is on the rise, thanks to dozens of unhealthy deals between TV newsrooms and hospitals

Citation metadata

Author: Trudy Lieberman
Date: March-April 2007
From: Columbia Journalism Review(Vol. 45, Issue 6)
Publisher: Columbia University, Graduate School of Journalism
Document Type: Article
Length: 4,208 words

Main content

Article Preview :

When 19 thousand viewers tuned in to the 7 a.m. news on KTBC-TV, the local Fox channel in Austin, Texas, in mid-January, they heard the anchor, Joe Bickett, introduce a story about a new electronic rehabilitation system for injured kids. "Sharon Dennis has more on that," Bickett said. Dennis then described how a lively fifteen-year-old named Merrill, who had sprained her ankle, was getting better thanks to the computer-guided rehab program that Cleveland Clinic researchers are calling "the world's first virtual-only gym."

The professional-looking story had that gee-whiz feel so typical of TV health news, explaining how the technology was making it easier for patients to get back to normal. It ended with "Sharon Dennis reporting."

Viewers could be forgiven if they thought they were seeing real news reported by one of the station's reporters. But Sharon Dennis does not work for KTBC. The story had been fed to the station by the Cleveland Clinic, the health care behemoth. Dennis, who earned her broadcasting bona tides at ABC News and at KOMO-TV in Seattle, works in Cleveland as the executive producer of the Cleveland Clinic News Service, in a windowless office on the fourth floor of the Intercontinental Hotel on the clinic's sprawling 140-acre campus. There the clinic has constructed broadcast facilities for Dennis and her four person staff, complete with three cameras, a background set, and an ON AIR sign purchased at Target. Every day, Dennis sends out prepackaged stories to, among others, Fox News Edge, a service for Fox affiliates that in turn distributes the pieces to 140 Fox stations. What Texas viewers heard that January morning was a script written at the Intercontinental Hotel.

In essence, the story was a hybrid of news and marketing, the likes of which has spread to local TV newsrooms all across the country in a variety of forms, almost like an epidemic. It's the product of a marriage of the hospitals' desperate need to compete for lucrative lines of business in our current health system and of TV's hunger for cheap and easy stories. In some cases the hospitals pay for airtime, a sponsorship, and in others, they don't but still provide expertise and story ideas. Either way, the result is that too often the hospitals control the story. Viewers who think they are getting news are really getting a form of advertising. And critical stories-hospital infection rates, for example, or medical mistakes or poor care-tend not to be covered in such a cozy atmosphere. The public, which could use real health reporting these days, gets something far less than quality, arms-length journalism.

The story about the virtual gym--which ran on twenty-one other stations, too--ended with Bickett saying that its developers hope to have the technology available in hospitals around the U.S. by the end of the year. Though he didn't mention which hospitals, viewers could easily conclude that the Cleveland Clinic was one of them. Indeed that is what the clinic hopes. Cleveland Clinic News Service stories almost always feature...

Source Citation

Source Citation
Lieberman, Trudy. "Epidemic: phony medical news is on the rise, thanks to dozens of unhealthy deals between TV newsrooms and hospitals." Columbia Journalism Review, vol. 45, no. 6, 2007, p. 38+. Accessed 10 Apr. 2021.

Gale Document Number: GALE|A164948233